|
||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
ARTICLE |
Correspondence to Ian C. Forster: Iforster{at}access.unizh.ch
|
|
|---|
F), which suggested that this site lies in an environment that is affected by conformational change in the protein.
F was substrate dependent (no
F was detectable in 0 mM Na+) and showed little correlation with presteady-state charge movements, indicating that the two signals provide insight into different underlying physical processes. Interpretation of ion substitution experiments indicated that the substrate binding order differs from our previous model (Forster, I., N. Hernando, J. Biber, and H. Murer. 1998. J. Gen. Physiol. 112:118). In the new model, two (rather than one) Na+ ions precede Pi binding, and only the second Na+ binding transition is voltage dependent. Moreover, we show that Li+, which does not drive cotransport, interacts with the first Na+ binding transition. The results were incorporated in a new model of the transport cycle of type II Na+/Pi cotransporters, the validity of which is supported by simulations that successfully predict the voltage and substrate dependency of the experimentally determined fluorescence changes.
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The transport kinetics of electrogenic type II Na+/Pi cotransporters have been studied in detail by electrophysiology and uptake assays (for review see Forster et al., 2002
) by means of heterologous expression in Xenopus oocytes. Type IIa Na+/Pi cotransporters are functional monomers (Kohler et al., 2000
) and we assume that this holds true for all three subtypes. A kinetic model has been developed based on analysis of substrate-induced steady-state currents and presteady-state charge movements. According to the model, the electrogenic NaPi-II transport cycle comprises ordered binding (on the extracellular side) of one Na+ ion, a divalent HPO42, followed by two more Na+ ions before translocation of the fully loaded carrier to the internal side. After unloading, the empty carrier returns to an external-facing configuration via an electrogenic partial reaction, and each complete forward transport cycle transfers one positive charge to the intracellular medium (Forster et al., 1997
, 1998
, 2000; Virkki et al., 2005
).
The documentation of substrate-dependent presteady-state charge movements for NaPi-IIa/b proteins supported the notion that voltage-dependent conformational changes accompany substrate binding/debinding and translocation. Furthermore, for NaPi-IIa/b, we have documented presteady-state charge movements in the absence of substrate (Forster et al., 1997
, 1998
, 2000; Virkki et al., 2005
); these are assumed to reflect voltage-dependent molecular rearrangements of the empty carrier itself. In general, however, such presteady-state charge movements may arise from a global response of mobile charges distributed throughout the protein to changes in the transmembrane electric field. Moreover, electrically silent transitions are detected only indirectly through their effect on voltage-dependent events. Therefore, their usefulness as a means to localize regions or sites undergoing conformational changes may be limited.
Voltage clamp fluorometry (VCF) offers a means to overcome these limitations by allowing real-time recording of fluorescence changes of a fluorophore covalently attached to a selected site. The method relies on the property that the fluorescence of a fluorophore is sensitive to its local environment, and that conformational changes in the environment of the fluorophore may therefore effect a fluorescence change. A particular advantage of VCF is that fluorescence changes in response to changes in substrate and membrane voltage can be followed in real time; moreover, unlike presteady-state charge movement assays, detection of conformationally sensitive sites does not necessitate the movement of charged particles in an electric field. VCF was originally developed for the study of gating-induced conformational changes in K+ channels (Mannuzzu et al., 1996
; Cha and Bezanilla, 1997
). Since then, VCF has been applied to several membrane transporter systems, including the glucose transporter SGLT1 (Loo et al., 1998
; Meinild et al., 2002
), the glutamate transporter EAAT3 (Larsson et al., 2004
), the GABA transporter GAT1 (Li et al., 2000
), the serotonin transporter SERT (Li and Lester, 2002
), and the Na+/K+-and H+/K+ ATPases (Geibel et al., 2003a
,b
). We therefore decided to apply VCF to the Na+/Pi cotransporter to identify parts of the protein that are involved in conformational change during substrate binding and translocation, and to shed new light on the individual kinetic steps of the transport cycle.
Wild-type (WT) NaPi-II proteins contain 1314 cysteines, none of which is normally accessible to external methanethiosulfonate (MTS) reagents. As the first site to be investigated, we chose a previously identified mutation (S460C) in the rat NaPi-IIa isoform that appeared to show substrate-dependent changes in its MTS accessibility (Lambert et al., 1999
). This mutant displays WT-like kinetics, but after modification of the cysteine, cotransport function is suppressed. However, substrate binding still appears to be intact, which would allow study of conformational changes associated with substrate binding and/or membrane voltage. An advantage of the suppression of cotransport function by MTS modification is that it gives a readily measurable readout of cysteine modification at this site, and therefore we can use this property to study the effect of membrane voltage and substrate on the accessibility of the site. Moreover, the lack of cotransport activity means that the number of distinct conformational states is reduced, thereby potentially simplifying interpretation of data in terms of kinetic schemes. Although the original mutation was created in the rat NaPi-IIa isoform, we chose the flounder NaPi-IIb isoform for VCF measurements because its expression level in oocytes is high, with Pi-induced currents up to 10 times those of the rat isoform (Forster et al., 1997
).
| MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The standard experimental solution (ND100) contained (in mM) 100 NaCl, 2 KCl, 1.8 CaCl2, 1 MgCl2, 10 HEPES, pH 7.4 (adjusted using Tris). In Na+ replacement experiments, NaCl was equimolarly replaced with choline Cl, LiCl, or KCl. Solutions containing the required concentrations of Pi were prepared by adding K2HPO4/KH2PO4 (pH 7.4). Modified Barth's solution for storing oocytes contained (in mM) 88 NaCl, 1 KCl, 0.41 CaCl2, 0.82 MgSO4, 2.5 NaHCO3, 2 Ca(NO3)2, 7.5 HEPES, pH 7.5 adjusted with Tris and supplemented with 5 mg/l doxycyclin.
Oocyte Expression and Molecular Biology
cDNA encoding wild-type (WT) flounder NaPi-IIb (GenBank/EMBL/DDBJ accession no. AAB16821) was subcloned into a vector containing the 5' and 3' UTRs from Xenopus ß-globin to improve its expression in oocytes. Mutant S448C was generated using the Quikchange site-directed mutagenesis kit from Stratagene and sequenced (Microsynth). Complementary capped RNA was synthesized using the T3 Message Machine kit (Ambion).
Adult female Xenopus laevis were purchased from Xenopus Express France or African Xenopus Facility (R. South Africa). Portions of ovaries were surgically removed from anaesthetized (0.1% Tricaine) animals and cut into small pieces. Oocytes were defolliculated using a 3545-min treatment in ND100 solution (without Ca2+) containing 2 mg/ml collagenase (crude type 1A) and 0.2 mg/ml trypsin inhibitor type III-O. After extensive washing with Ca2+-free ND100 solution, stage VVI oocytes were selected and maintained in modified Barth's solution at 16°C. Oocytes were injected with 50 nl of cRNA (0.2 µg/µl) and experiments performed 37 d after injection. Prior to fluorescence measurements, oocytes were voltage clamped to 90 mV and exposed for 5 min to 0.4 mM MTS-TMR in ND100 solution in the dark. The Pi-induced current response was recorded before and after labeling to ensure complete labeling of S448C (no significant Pi-induced currents observed after labeling). The treatment did not alter the normal Pi current response of the WT.
Conventional Two-electrode Voltage Clamp
The procedure for standard two-electrode voltage clamp has been described in detail previously (Forster et al., 1998
). Membrane voltage was controlled and transmembrane current measured using a laboratory-built voltage clamp system that achieved clamping of a model oocyte (membrane capacitance 220 nF, leak resistance 200 k
) with a 1090% rise time = 0.65 ms. Data were acquired using a Digidata 1322A (Molecular Devices Corp.) driven by pClamp 9 software. The oocyte was mounted in a chamber optimized for rapid solution exchange and continuously perfused at a rate of 5 ml/min. For constant voltage recordings, currents were acquired at 20 samples/s and filtered at 10 Hz. Faster sampling rates (up to 20k samples/s) were used for voltage-jump recordings, with filtering adjusted accordingly.
Steady-state and presteady-state kinetics were determined using previously described protocols (Forster et al., 1998
) by applying voltage steps in the range 160 mV to +80 mV from a 60 mV holding potential (Vh). In brief, steady-state Pi activation was determined by varying the Pi concentration always in the presence of ND100 and subtracting the respective currents in ND100 from those in ND100 + Pi; steady-state Na+ activation was similarly determined by subtracting the respective responses in NDX from those in NDX+Pi (1 mM), where X is the test Na+ concentration (in mM). Steady-state Pi-induced currents (
) were fit with a form of the modified Hill equation:
![]() | (1) |
is the maximum electrogenic activity, KmS the apparent substrate affinity for substrate S, H the Hill coefficient, and K is a constant that takes account of uncoupled leak effects (Ehnes et al., 2004a
Presteady-state relaxations were quantitated from the records obtained in 0 mM Pi, by fitting with a two-component exponential function. The faster component was assumed to represent endogenous linear capacitive charging of the oocyte and was subtracted from the total relaxation to yield the NaPi-IIdependent component. This was numerically integrated to obtain the charge Q moved for a step from Vh to the test potential (V), as previously described (e.g., Ehnes et al., 2004a
; Virkki et al., 2005
). The Q-V data were fit with a Boltzmann function of the form:
![]() | (2) |
Incubation with MTS reagents and reaction rate determinations were done as described previously (Lambert et al., 2001
; Ehnes et al., 2004b
). The oocyte was placed in the recording chamber and the holding current monitored continuously. After applying 1 mM Pi to determine the initial current response at 50 mV, freshly prepared MTSEA (2.5 µM) or MTSES (25 µM) in ND100 solution was applied to the oocyte for a set period of time, while the membrane voltage was held at either Vh = 90 or 0 mV. After a 1-min washout, the current response to 1 mM Pi at Vh = 50 mV was again determined and the MTS application was repeated. The MTS concentrations were optimized in preliminary experiments to allow for convenient determination of the modification rate.
The Pi-induced current remaining after each successive application of MTS reagent was extracted and plotted as a function of the cumulative exposure time, normalized to the initial Pi-induced current. The data were fit with a single decaying exponential to determine the effective second order reaction constant using an equation of the form
![]() | (3) |
is the Pi-induced current after a cumulative exposure time t,
is the initial Pi-induced current,
is the Pi-induced current at infinity, c is the concentration of MTS reagent (assumed to be in excess), and k is the effective second order rate constant (Zhang and Karlin, 1997
Assay for 32Pi Uptake
Pi uptake measurements using radioactive 32Pi on control oocytes or oocytes expressing WT or S448C NaPi-IIb were performed as follows. Groups of six to eight oocytes were preincubated in ND100 solution containing 1 mM MTSEA for 5 min. This solution was replaced with 100 µl ND100 solution containing 1 mM MTSEA, 1 mM cold Pi, and 1 µCi 32Pi. Uptake was allowed to proceed for 10 min and then the oocytes were washed thrice with ice-cold ND0 solution containing 2 mM Pi, and finally lysed individually in 10% SDS. The amount of radioactivity trapped in each oocyte was measured using scintillation counting.
Apparatus for Simultaneous Voltage Clamp and Fluorometry
The voltage clamp hardware, data acquisition hardware, and software were the same as described above with an additional channel for fluorescence. In addition, we acquired continuous current and fluorescence signals separately with a Minidigi 1A and Axoscope software (Molecular Devices Corp). The recording chamber and arrangement of the optical components was adapted from a system originally developed by D.D.F. Loo and B. Hirayama (University of California Los Angeles, CA). The recording chamber had a volume of
40 µl with a 0.5-mm-thick glass coverslip as its base, upon which the oocyte was positioned and mechanically stabilized by the two microelectrodes. These were standard 3 M KCl-filled pipettes with resistances of typically 25 M
. An Ag/AgCl pellet served as the bath electrode. As noted by Meinild et al. (2002)
, we also found that mounting the oocyte with animal (dark) pole facing the chamber bottom resulted in lowest background fluorescence. The oocyte was continuously superfused by a gravity-feed system that allowed up to eight different solutions to be independently applied. Solution exchange in the chamber was achieved within
10 s.
The optical unit comprised a fluorescence objective mounted on a stable enclosure that housed the filter set and associated components. The optical unit was mounted on an X-Y translation stage (M406, Newport) that allowed centering of the oocyte within the excitation beam. Fluorescence was excited by a 100-W halogen light source powered from a stabilized DC source. For stability the light was operated continuously during the experimental session and an electronic shutter (VS252T1, Uniblitz, Vincent Assoc.) was mounted between the light source and optical unit to avoid photobleaching when not recording. The shutter controller was adapted from the manufacturer's OEM design (Vincent Assoc.) and allowed either manual control or software control by the 1322A interface. Excitation and emission wavelengths were nominally 535 and 605 nm, respectively, achieved using an XF33 filter set, which comprised a 535DF35 excitation filter, 570DRLP dichroic mirror, and 605DF50 emission filter (Omega Optical Inc.). The excitation beam was focused on the oocyte using a x10 fluorescence objective (CFI S Fluor, 0.5 N.A., 1.2 mm W.D., Nikon), the vertical position of which could be adjusted for optimal beam focusing. The
-focus emission beam was reflected at 45° using a mirror (20SJ00ER.3, Newport) that was mounted below the XF33 cube. The emerging horizontal beam was focused using a convex lens (O-PCL-13, Vision GmbH) onto a Si photodiode (S1336-18BQ, Hamamatsu). The diode and lens were mounted in a separate enclosure at the side of the optical unit.
The photodiode was connected directly to the input of a CV 201 integrating headstage (Axon Instruments), and the headstage signal was processed by an Axopatch 200A patch clamp amplifier (Axon Instruments) to give an output voltage:diode current conversion ratio of 1 mV/pA (scaled output gain = 1) and a nominal bandwidth of 10 kHz. To improve the signal-to-noise ratio further when measuring voltage step-evoked fluorescence changes, the scaled output of the Axopatch 200 was processed by a differential amplifier/filter unit (LPF-8, Warner) before digitization. This allowed independent subtraction of the background fluorescence signal from the photodiode output (using a stable, low noise, adjustable voltage reference) before final amplification and filtering. The effective dark noise of the fluorescence hardware was typically
0.4 pA rms (5 kHz bandwidth) referred to the input of the integrating headstage, and at this bandwidth the fluorescence signal exhibited a 1090% rise time = 0.075 ms, determined using an LED-generated light pulse coupled to the recording chamber via an optical fiber. To confirm that the VCF setup was working properly, we used oocytes expressing the Q457C mutant of human SGLT1 (a gift of E. Wright, University of California Los Angeles, CA).
Experimental Protocols
Changes in fluorescence were measured in response to changing substrate concentrations and changing membrane potential. Fluorescence signals were expressed as a percentage of the background fluorescence determined at Vh = 60 mV. For the normalized data in the voltage jump experiments, F is expressed in arbitrary units (a.u.).
In the first set of experiments (steady-state experiments) we studied the influence of changing substrate by measuring the change in steady-state F in response to an increase in the Na+ concentration (range: 10125 mM), Li+ concentration (range: 10100 mM) or Pi concentration (range: 0.011 mM in 100 mM Na+). Each test substrate concentration was bracketed with a control solution to allow for correction of fluorescence rundown. The fluorescence signal was acquired after the new superfusate had been applied for 1.52.5 min to ensure equilibration of solution also under the oocyte, from which most of the fluorescence signal was assumed to arise. After equilibration, the shutter was opened 710 times in succession for 230 ms at 2.23-s intervals to minimize photobleaching (see Fig. 3 A), and the signal was averaged over these openings to minimize error due to noise. During the shutter opening time, the membrane potential was stepped from Vh = 60 to 120 mV (Na+ and Li+ experiments) or from Vh = 60 to 0 mV (Pi experiments) to acquire
F-substrate data at two voltages. The data were corrected for fluorescence rundown (see below).
In the second set of experiments we extended the voltage range over which voltage-dependent changes in fluorescence (
F) were investigated by using a voltage-step protocol. This also allowed us to follow the time course of the voltage-induced fluorescence change by matching the bandwidths of the current and fluorescent signals. Except when noted otherwise, the membrane voltage was stepped from Vh = 60 mV to test potentials ranging between 200 and +80 mV in 40-mV increments for a duration of 100 ms, and averaged over 10 sweeps. Data were acquired at different Na+, Li+, and Pi concentrations as described above. To correct for photobleaching, every third recording was done in 100 mM Na+ (experiments with variable Na+ or Pi) or 100 mM Li+ (experiments with variable Li+).
F data were acquired at 20k samples/s and filtered at 40 or 500 Hz for steady-state and presteady-state analysis, respectively. The F traces acquired for each substrate concentration were baseline corrected to the value at Vh = 60 mV and also corrected for photobleaching (see below). Each recording was then offset with respect to the zero-substrate condition to take into account that F at Vh = 60 mV was substrate concentration dependent. The amount of offset necessary was estimated from the data acquired using the steady-state experiments described above.
For presteady-state fluorescence measurements, the voltage jump protocol was modified by shortening the time spent at each target potential to 40 ms to reduce photobleaching and by increasing the number of averages to 64 to improve the signal-to-noise ratio without sacrificing signal bandwidth, which was set to 500 Hz for both the current and F signals.
Correcting for Fluorescence Rundown and Photobleaching
During the course of an experiment, fluorescence decreased, and this decrease fell into two categories. On the one hand, there was a slow rundown of the steady-state fluorescence that was independent of exposure to light, and which followed an exponential time course with a half time (t1/2
1 h). This rundown probably resulted from washout of unbound dye and/or internalization of membrane proteins covalently labeled with dye and was noticeable during the steady-state experiments even in the absence of light exposure (see Fig. 3 A). On the other hand, light-induced photobleaching of the dye proceeded with t1/2
5 min with the lamp set to maximum light intensity and was the dominant type of fluorescence decrease in the voltage jump experiments.
All data were corrected for the decrease in fluorescence during the experiment by normalizing to the extrapolated value at t = 0. In the voltage jump experiments, we plotted
F acquired in the control solutions at different voltages (after zeroing for Vh = 60 mV) as a function of cumulative light exposure time and fitted with a single decaying exponential. For the steady-state experiments, we plotted the fluorescence data acquired in the control solution as a function of time elapsed after the start of the experiment (in these experiments the contribution of photobleaching to the fluorescence decrease was minimal). We fitted the data with a single decaying exponential plus an offset, which takes into account that the fluorescence will never reach zero (even a nonlabeled oocyte gives a definite fluorescence signal when placed in the experimental chamber). In both cases, the approach was validated, because it successfully corrected the fluorescence change seen in control solutions during the course of an experiment.
Data Analysis
The fluorescence response to a change in substrate concentration, determined for different membrane voltages, was fitted with the modified Hill equation of the form
![]() | (4) |
Fmax is the extrapolated maximum fluorescence, KmS is the concentration of S that gives a half-maximum response, and H is the Hill coefficient. Presteady-state
F data were fit with an exponential growth function to estimate the ON time constant (
F) (Clampfit, v9.2, Molecular Devices Corp).
Simulations
Computer simulations were performed as described earlier (Forster et al., 1998
; Virkki et al., 2005
). In brief, voltage- and substrate-dependent changes in fluorescence were simulated by assigning rate constants to the transitions between the states shown in Fig. 8 A. Voltage-dependent rates were formulated according to Eyring transition rate theory, assuming sharp energy barriers. We assumed that the empty carrier states (1 and 8 in Fig. 7 A) were associated with the highest fluorescence and that a reduction in the occupancy of these states resulted in a proportional decrease in fluorescence.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
) typically in the range 200 to 800 nA at Vh = 50 mV (unpublished data), depending on the oocyte batch and time after injection. As shown in Fig. 1 (B and C), the magnitude and voltage dependency of the apparent Pi and Na+ affinities (
and KmNa, respectively) were indistinguishable from the WT. Moreover, for Na+ activation at constant Pi (1 mM), the Hill coefficient (H) and predicted maximum Pi-induced current (
) showed similar voltage dependencies (unpublished data). These data confirmed that the Ser to Cys substitution at site 448 did not alter the basic electrogenic cotransport kinetics.
|
) for the control and MTS-TMR conditions. Fig. 1 E shows the steady-state I-V data for
at each test voltage, pooled and normalized to
at 100 mV in the control condition (n = 4). These data show that MTS exposure largely eliminated the electrogenic cotransport activity over the entire range of test potentials. We also noted that for superfusion in ND100, MTS exposure appeared to suppress the presteady-state currents that follow the step onset and are partially superimposed on the oocyte capacitive transient (Fig. 1 D, left). These currents are the subject of a more detailed analysis below. In general, this behavior was similar to that of the rat NaPi-IIa isoform (mutant S460C; Lambert et al., 1999
As the electrogenic cotransport function of S448C was blocked by treatment with MTS reagents, we exploited this property to determine the effect of membrane holding potential on the reaction rates of MTS reagents bearing a positive (MTSEA) or a negative (MTSES) charge. The reaction rates for MTSEA were determined both in the presence and absence of Na+, whereas MTSES was applied only in the presence of Na+. Fig. 2 A shows the progressive decrease in
with increasing cumulative MTS exposure times. We estimated the effective second-order rate constant k by fitting the data with Eq. 3, as summarized in Table I. For MTSEA (Fig. 2, C and D), the reaction rate constants were almost threefold smaller when the incubation was performed in the presence of Na+ (ND100) compared with incubation in 0 mM Na+ (ND0). Furthermore, the reaction rate constants were
2.5 times smaller at Vh = 90 mV, compared with 0 mV, independent of the charge of the MTS reagent or whether or not Na+ was present. These results indicated that (a) the reactive site Cys-448 does not lie within the membrane electrical field, (b) hyperpolarization of the membrane induced a conformational change in the NaPi-IIb protein that increased the apparent accessibility of Cys-448 for MTS reagents, and (c) accessibility to this site increased in the presence of external Na+. The slower reaction rate for MTSES (Fig. 2 B), compared with MTSEA, can be accounted for in part due to its overall slower reaction rate with small thiols in solution (Karlin and Akabas, 1998
). Moreover, like MTSEA and MTSES, the rate of labeling with MTS-TMR showed a qualitatively similar dependency on the incubation holding potential (unpublished data).
|
|
|
After correction for rundown, the Na+-dependent change in fluorescence (
F) was determined for the two potentials and plotted as a function of the Na+ concentration.
F/F data from a representative oocyte is shown in Fig. 3 B. The data were fitted with the Hill equation (Eq. 4). The Hill coefficient H reported by the fit was 1.7 ± 0.4 and 1.7 ± 0.2 for 60 and 120 mV, respectively, for the oocyte shown, and after H = 1.6 ± 0.5 for both potentials tested (n = 4). The result indicated cooperative binding of more than one Na+ ion. The estimate of KmNa from the fit was unreliable due to lack of saturation, but suggested a KmNa >150 mM.
To determine whether Li+ (which is physically smaller than Na+) can also interact with the transporter, we performed similar experiments as shown in Fig. 3 A but with Li+ as the variable substrate. Li+ produced a qualitatively similar but smaller decrease in F than Na+. After correction for rundown, we plotted the Li+-dependent change in F as a function of the Li+ concentration and fitted the data with Eq. 4. Fig. 3 C shows
F/F data from a representative oocyte. In contrast to the Na+ data, the Li+ data did not show a sigmoidal doseresponse, but were best described with H in Eq. 4 constrained to 1, i.e., a Michaelis-Menten function. The KmLi reported by the fit was unreliable, but indicated KmLi >200 mM (n = 5). These results document, for the first time, that Li+ can interact with the NaPi-IIb transporter. Furthermore, the interaction differs from that of Na+ in that no cooperativity was evident, suggesting that the change in fluorescence occurs with the binding of only one Li+ ion.
Finally, we examined the effect of Pi on the steady-state fluorescence. Pi was applied in ND100 solution using a similar protocol as shown in Fig. 3 A, with the exception that during the shutter opening time, the membrane potential was stepped from 60 to 0 mV. Applying Pi decreased F in a concentration-dependent manner. The Pi-induced decrease in F was derived after correction for fluorescence rundown and plotted as a function of the Pi concentration in Fig. 3 D. In these experiments obvious saturation was obtained with increasing Pi concentrations. This allowed for normalization of the data obtained from individual oocytes to the extrapolated Fmax measured at 0 mV before pooling the data. The data were refit with the Hill equation with H constrained to 1. The apparent KmPi reported by the fit was 0.097 ± 0.03 mM for 60 mV and 0.11 ± 0.02 for 0 mV (n = 5).
As a control, we repeated the above protocols on oocytes expressing WT NaPi-IIb labeled with MTS-TMR under the same conditions. No changes in F above background noise were seen after changing Na+, Li+, or Pi, indicating that the effects on F seen in the above experiments are specific to S448C (unpublished data).
S448C Shows Voltage and Na+-dependent Changes in Steady-state Fluorescence
Next, we examined the voltage dependency of the S448C-dependent fluorescence signal in more detail. We obtained current recordings similar to those shown in Fig. 4 A with variable amounts of Na+ or Li+ in the bath. Each recording was initially baseline corrected for Vh = 60 mV to obtain
F, and then shifted with respect to the zero substrate condition using data obtained in the steady-state experiments described above (Fig. 3 B) as reference. This procedure was adopted because the fluorescence signal did not saturate at hyperpolarizing potentials precluding, for example, fitting the data with a Boltzmann function.
|
F was only observed in oocytes expressing S448C and labeled with MTS-TMR. No voltage-dependent
F was observed in noninjected oocytes or oocytes expressing WT NaPi-IIb labeled under the same conditions as S448C (unpublished data).
F showed saturation for jumps to more positive potentials, but no saturation was observed for negative jumps (200 mV is the most negative command voltage possible with the voltage clamp). As a consequence, the maximum decrease in F attainable with hyperpolarization is unknown. We also established that F was independent of the starting potential by applying the same series of final test potentials for starting potentials 200, 60, and +80 mV (unpublished data). For each test potential,
F varied with the starting potential whereas F at the test potential depended only on the test potential. This confirmed that the fluorescence signal F represented a memoryless process. We determined the Na+ dependency of F by substituting Na+ in the bath with equimolar choline. Fig. 4 B shows that for a given nonzero Na+ concentration, F decreased with hyperpolarization. The variation in F with voltage became smaller as the external Na+ was decreased, until at 0 mM Na+, F was essentially voltage independent. At depolarizing potentials, F appeared to asymptote to the same level for all Na+ concentrations. In contrast to the presteady-state current measurements, where saturation was observed at the limits of both hyper- and hypopolarizing voltages (see below), the lack of saturation of F at negative potentials precluded a reliable fit of a Boltzmann function (Eq. 2) to the data. Instead, we determined an apparent KmNa for the Na+ dependency of the fluorescence signal at each potential by replotting the data in Fig. 4 B as a function of the Na+ concentration and fitting the data with Eq. 4 (Fig. 4 C). Fig. 4 D shows a plot of the apparent KmNa as a function of the membrane potential. KmNa is clearly voltage dependent and increases with depolarizing potentials, which suggested that the binding of Na+ is voltage dependent. The Hill coefficient did not show any apparent voltage dependency. It averaged 1.8 ± 0.2 for the different potentials, which suggested that more than one Na+ ion interacted with the protein. Most significantly, this showed that although the electrogenic cotransport activity of the labeled S448C mutant was suppressed (see Fig. 1 D), Na+ ions were still able to interact with the protein.
Effect of Other Cations on Fluorescence
Na+ is the only known cation that can drive Pi cotransport in the NaPi-II family, however other cations may interact with partial reactions in the transport cycle, as has been shown for H+ (Forster et al., 2000
; Virkki et al., 2005
) and for Li+ in the steady-state experiments (Fig. 3 C) described above. First, we replaced Na+ equimolarly with Li+ (LD100) and measured voltage-dependent
F in MTS-TMRlabeled S448C. F showed a qualitatively similar voltage dependency in LD100 as in ND100. The fluorescence signal saturated at positive voltages, but not at negative voltages. Compared with ND100, in LD100,
F (measured between +80 and 200 mV) was reduced by
50%. Furthermore, the time constant for
F in response to a voltage step was slower in LD100 than in ND100 (see below). Finally, adding 1 mM Pi to LD100 solution did not affect
F.
Reducing Li+ in the bath (replaced equimolarly with choline) led to a concomitant reduction of the voltage-dependent
F. As in the experiments with variable Na+ described above, the fluorescence traces acquired at each Li+ concentrations were offset with respect to the zero substrate condition using data obtained in the steady-state experiments as reference. Fig. 4 E shows the effect of changing the Li+ concentration on the voltage dependency of F. We replotted F as a function of the Li+ concentration and fitted the data with Eq. 4 (Fig. 4 F). The initial fit yielded an average Hill coefficient of 0.93 ± 0.07 over the voltage range tested. We therefore constrained H to unity to reduce the fit uncertainty. KmLi ranged between 100 and 300 mM (Fig. 4 G), but the fit uncertainty was still quite large due to lack of saturation of the signal at the highest Li+ concentration used.
Replacing Na+ with K+ abolished the voltage dependency of F, which indicated that unlike Na+ and Li+, K+ ions do not interact with the transporter (unpublished data). Finally, reducing external pH from 7.4 to 6.2 did not alter the
F signal (unpublished data). In summary, the conformational changes reported by the fluorescence were not supported by K+ and unaffected by an
10-fold increase in the proton concentration.
Pi Dependency of Fluorescence
Finally, we investigated the voltage dependency of F in response to Pi in MTS-TMRlabeled S448C. Adding 1 mM Pi to ND100 solution strongly suppressed
F over the voltage range measured (Fig. 5 A). Fig. 5 B shows the voltage dependency of F at different Pi concentrations. Each trace was offset for Vh = 60 mV with respect to the 0 mM Pi condition using data obtained in the steady-state experiments (Fig. 3 D) as reference. Increasing the Pi concentration reduced F mostly at depolarizing voltages, in a concentration-dependent manner. Like the 0 mM Pi data (Fig. 4, B and E), no saturation was observed at negative voltages, which precluded a Boltzmann analysis of the data. Instead, we replotted the data in Fig. 5 B as a function of the Pi concentration (Fig. 5 C). Fitting the data with Eq. 4 yielded a
of
100 µM, with no apparent voltage dependency (Fig. 5 D). For these fits, we constrained the Hill coefficient to unity to reduce the fit error (the initial fit with H as a variable yielded an average Hill coefficient of 1.0 ± 0.03 over the voltage range tested).
|
|
20%) increase when external Na+ ions were removed due to the change in conductivity of the bath solution affecting the voltage clamp response (unpublished data). On the other hand, the slower component showed an obvious voltage dependency, with a distinct maximum, as well as dependency on the external Na+ concentration (Fig. 6 B, left). Before labeling, the time constant showed a peak that shifted to more depolarizing potentials as Na+ increased and agreed with previous data for the WT NaPi-IIb (Forster et al., 1997
Fig. 6 C compares the charge obtained by numerical integration of the slow relaxation before (left) and after (right) labeling for the same representative oocyte at different external Na+ concentrations indicated. These data were fit with a single Boltzmann function (Eq. 2). To better visualize the effect of changing external Na+, the data and associated Boltzmann curve were offset so that they superimposed at the same depolarizing limit predicted from the fit for ND125. The fit parameters are shown in Fig. 6 D as a function of external Na+, pooled from five oocytes. The midpoint potential of the Boltzmann fit (V0.5, Fig. 6 D, left) shifted to more hyperpolarizing potentials as we decreased external Na+ and showed a linear relationship when plotted against log10 [Na+] in the 25125 mM range. The slope of the linear regression line increased from 86 ± 12 mV/decade-[Na+] before labeling to 121 ± 17 mV/decade-[Na+] after labeling. Before labeling, the apparent valency from the Boltzmann fit (z) for S448C increased slightly with increasing Na+. After labeling, z was not sensitive to Na+ and was
30% smaller at high Na+ than before labeling. The slope and z estimates reported here for S448C were comparable with values obtained from WT NaPi-IIb cells, which yielded a linear regression slope = 111 ± 14 mV/decade [Na+] (n = 4) and a mean z = 0.56 for 25 mM
[Na+]
125 mM. Finally, the predicted maximum charge available for mobilization (Qmax) was reduced by 50%, relative to unlabeled S448C, for all Na+ concentrations. We were able to fit the Na+-dependent component of the Qmax data with the Hill equation (Eq. 1) with H constrained to 1 and an offset corresponding to Qmax in ND0. The apparent KmNa reported by the fit was 16 ± 6 mM and increased to 38 ± 14 mM after labeling. In addition to blocking the cotransport function, these findings established that modification of S448C resulted in altered presteady-state kinetics.
We also recorded presteady-state relaxations in Li+ solution (LD100) (unpublished data) and derived Boltzmann parameters from these data (Table II). For unmodified S448C-expressing oocytes, replacing Na+ with Li+ resulted in a reduction in the predicted Qmax comparable to that obtained with choline replacement (ND0). In contrast, V0.5 was not statistically different between ND100 and LD100. The apparent equality of Qmax between ND0 and LD100 was also maintained after Cys modification, however V0.5 for the charge distribution in LD100 was shifted toward hyperpolarizing potentials and was statistically indistinguishable from V0.5 for ND0. These findings established that for the unmodified cotransporter, Li+ ions did not contribute to overall charge movement, although their presence altered the steady-state distribution of mobile charge. After modification, the invariance of the Boltzmann fit parameters within the experimental error indicated that superfusion in LD100 was indistinguishable from ND0.
|
F at the same bandwidth as for the presteady-state relaxations (500 Hz). Fig. 7 A shows representative fluorescence (
F) and current (Ipss) recordings from a labeled S448C-expressing oocyte for voltage steps in the range 160 to + 40 mV for three superfusion conditions: 100 mM Na+ (ND100), 100 mM Choline+ (ND0), and 100 mM Li+ (LD100). S448C-related presteady-state relaxations were resolved, as described above, and the main relaxation component (I2) was extracted, as shown. There was a clear difference in the time course of the voltage stepinduced
F between ND100 and LD100 superfusion. In the latter case, a steady- state
F was reached only after
50 ms (see also Fig. 4 A). For ND100, the time course of I2 and the rising phase of
F appeared qualitatively similar, whereas for LD100 superfusion, we were unable to detect a similarly slow component of charge movement. To better visualize any correlation between charge movement and fluorescence for ND100 superfusion, we plotted
F parametrically against I2 as a function of time for the same oocyte (Fig. 7 B). There was an obvious linear dependency for V > 40 mV, as would be predicted for a correlation between
F and I2, but this dependency did not hold at hyperpolarizing potentials.
|
F by fitting with a single exponential function. In ND100, the fluorescence time constant (
F) showed a weak voltage dependency (Fig. 7 C) and increased with hyperpolarizing potentials. For V > 0 mV, there was good agreement between 
F and the time constant associated with I2. In the hyperpolarizing region (V
40 mV), the two time constants differed significantly (P < 0.05). In contrast, for LD100, 
F was approximately fivefold larger than in ND100 and showed no clear voltage dependency in the measured range. | DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Effect of Modification on Steady-state Currents
Our current view of the location of Ser-448 is that it lies in a predicted loop region between transmembrane domains 5 and 6 (Fig. 1 A). Based on substituted cysteine accessibility studies, we believe that this loop is reentrant and contains
-helical elements (Lambert et al., 2001
). Previous work showed that in the rat NaPi-IIa isoform, modification of S460C (equivalent to S448C in the flounder) by MTSEA or MTSES was less efficient at depolarized potentials in the absence of Na+, however, in contrast to the present study, no effect of membrane potential on the modification was observed when Na+ was present. For flounder S448C, we found that the reaction rates were
2.5 times slower at 0 mV than at 90 mV independent of Na+, but removing Na+ slowed down the reaction rates for MTSEA 2.6-fold. In the previous study, MTSEA was applied for 2 min at a higher concentration (10 µM, as compared with 2.5 µM in this study) and the effective second order rate constants were not explicitly determined (Lambert et al., 1999